Collins triumphs at SPAC with 1920s feminist poem
By Barbara Fischkin, The Knickerbocker News, June 26, 1976
Judy Collins rested the old, pretty and safe folk tunes for a while Friday night and found new style with a staunch, but still sweet, 1920s suffragette poem unlike almost anything sung by balladeers of the sixties.
Playing at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center, the singer triumphed during her second act with “Bread and Roses,” a poem written 56 years ago to celebrate and explain activities of early feminists, and set to music recently by Mimi Farina.
Its execution was enhanced by “invisible singing women,” recorded voices which accompanied her while she sang about women marching for their rights, for the rights of men, for the bread or necessities of life, and also for the pleasures, the sweetness and the roses.
The lyrics are simple, and the music comes out sounding like it belongs both in a church and on a picket line. The effect, different and spiritual, moved the audience enough to cause Ms. Collins, who expressed high hopes for the piece, to admit backstage she was honestly shocked by their reaction.
“Bread and Roses” set the tone for a second act which was more striking because the singer performed works, which more often than not, expressed a woman’s viewpoint.
This is not to say there was anything seriously wrong with the first act. The 37-year-old singer came out looking youthful and excited in a flowing, striking white gown.
She was charming and proved her voice is still beautiful and interesting while singing many of the songs she is known for, including some by her idol Jacques Brel.
However, in comparison to the second act, she seemed almost too comfortable with some of them. There was also something disconcerting and almost mechanical about the way she floated into songs written by men, from their side of the world.
Steve Goodman’s “City of New Orleans,” about a native son’s American adventure, Jacques Brel’s 20-minute love affair with “Marieke,” and Leonard Cohen’s biblical “Isaac,” sung from the point of view of the nearly sacrificed son, all sounded lovely as expected during the first act. But they also all lacked a certain quality of the singer’s emotion. It was a quality one did not have to look for during the second act.
After intermission, in addition to “Bread and Roses,” Ms. Collins went to the piano to perform “Secret Gardens,” an original composition. Ms. Collins says she finds it very difficult to write and has told stories about the pressure she felt while composing this song. Even now, a few years later, the challenge it posed for her comes across and makes her rendition a more exciting one.
Other second act selections included “Someday Soon” and Stephen Sondheim’s “Send In The Clowns,” sung during an encore prompted by a standing ovation for both Ms. Collins and her new band.
The singer explained this was only their second

Recent Comments