Liberace’s ‘cornier than Kansas’
by Bruce Husten, The Knickerbocker News, August 2, 1976
Liberace, who bills himself as “Mr. Showmanship,” was cornier than Kansas in autumn at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center yesterday, and everybody loved it.
The razzle-dazzle glitter star put on two performances at SPAC yesterday, and the 3 p.m. show we saw brought the audience to its feet for several standing ovations, not just for Liberace, but for singer Debby Robert, a former Miss Louisiana who was on the bill with him, and for Scotty Plummer, the 15-year-old dynamic banjo player-performer whom Liberace calls his “protege.”
“Lee,” as his friends call the candelabra pianist, knows his audience well, and packed the amphitheater with that forgotten quantity known as the American “silent majority,” wowing them with technical felicity at the keyboard, a bit of bawdy humor and, of course, a series of totally outrageous outfits that bathe him in furs, minks, diamonds and glitter.
The “Mr. Showmanship” title is a deserved one, for that’s what this act is all about. It’s glitter and glamor, with a teensy bit of artistry mixed in. Liberace performed with both his guests and soloed himself in medleys of Gershwin, Eddie Duchin, Johann Strauss, and renditions of “Slaughter on Tenth Avenue,” “The Way We Were,” “Let Me Call You Sweetheart,” and other standards and pop tunes.
But the key came when he did a “medley,” if that’s a fair term to use here, of Chopin music. This is certainly no Rubinstein or Horowitz or even Van Cliburn, and it’s here that the truth comes out. Liberace has technique at the piano, but little else other than some good gimmickry and some good showmanship.
And it is therefore not surprising that young Scotty Plummer stole the show, particularly in a light-hearted but moving medley from “Fiddler on the Roof” and a duet with Lee of the “12th Street Rag.” This boy has talent and charisma and stage presence that is frightening for one so young, and his is indeed a name you’ll be hearing about.
Miss Robert offered a medley of Broadway show tunes, but she has a pseudo-operatic voice which didn’t quite fit the motif of the music, so the only of her pieces that really worked artistically was Gershwin’s “Summertime” from “Porgy and Bess.” She is, nevertheless, a breathtakingly beautiful woman whose attire in this show can lay the unique claim to being singularly unostentatious and not gawdy.
If Liberace lacks sensitivity as an artist, he has technique, a good rapport with his audience and a sense of humor.
Of one outfit, he says, “I don’t have it cleaned…I have it polished.
He plays a special song to celebrate a wedding in the audience. “I want to play this first,” he says sassily, “because they may have other plans. And this is a unique wedding. It’s the second time for both. She’s 65, and he’s 71. They requested a very beautiful song. (Pregnant pause.) ‘It’s Impossible.'”
As escapist entertainment, Liberace’s show rates four stars. On any other level, however, I agree (with the very noteworthy exception of young Scotty Plummer) that it is indeed impossible.

Recent Comments