Peter Allen: Singer, writer deserves much more fame

by Matthew Maguire, The Knickerbocker News, June 28, 1982

Imagine an eclectic performer who culled the best traits of Anthony Newley, Elton John and Lenny Bruce. Wouldn’t that make an interesting show?

It made a superb show Saturday night at Saratoga Performing Arts Center, when only 1,400 savvy persons, most of them preppies dressed as rainbows, witnessed a stunning tour de force by Peter Allen.

Who?

Peter Allen. Some know him as the ex-husband of Liza Minnelli, others as a gifted songwriter of material made famous by others. Apparently only a small but rabid following of fans know him as the complete performer nonpareil he showed himself to be Saturday. It shouldn’t be long before Allen shucks this ill-deserved anonymity.

With flawless support from an orchestra of 32 musicians — a seven-piece rock band up front complemented by complete brass and string sections — singer-songwriter Allen roared through two sets, one of 45 minutes, the other an hour, with unabated energy and a rare versatility.

From the opening pop samba, “I Go to Rio,” Allen never let up. In a style which is a curious blend of the flamboyant attack of John with passionate delivery of Newley, Allen sang, danced, and executed calisthenics on, over, under and around his grand piano, quickly relieving the audience of its preppie reserve and working it up into a frenzy just like his.

His compositions are always good and occasionally great. “I Could Have Been a Sailor,” a wistful tune about the roads not taken; “Tenterfield Saddler,” a tender love song for his grandfather, an Australian leatherworker; “Quiet, Please, There’s a Lady On-stage,” a moving tribute to his discoverer, Judy Garland; “You and Me,” a tune written for Frank Sinatra at Sinatra’s request; and “I’d Rather Leave While I’m in Love,” a tune about fading love — each has a musical depth and a lyrical grace not seen in today’s songwriting. Each could become a standard.

And those are just the ones you haven’t heard of. He wrote at least part of the modern standards “I Honestly Love You,” “Don’t Cry Out Loud,” and “Arthur’s Theme,” murdered on pop radio by Christopher Cross. His versions of these tunes Saturday night put the originals to shame.

Even the patter between tunes — delivered with a frenzy and spontaneity which reminds one, so help me, of Lenny Bruce — was better than that of many professional comedians.

Give these preppies credit: Their dress hits your eye like lye, but in this case they showed some taste. If Allen comes back to SPAC next year, try to catch this rising star.