Old, not new, works well for Mangione

by Steve Webb, The Knickerbocker News, July 12, 1982

One can judge Chuck Mangione’s music two ways. Judge it as jazz or some other similarly serious form and the flugelhornist-composer is bound to come out on the short end.

Some of it recalls jazz, or draws on his experience playing jazz, but it doesn’t have the improvisational edge of that form.

But judge Mangione’s music, which he performed at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center Sunday, as instrumental music without a distinct label, and he does all right. At his best, his music bursts with creativity — interesting melodies presented with a certain amount of freshness by his band. At its worst, his music sounds like background music on ’60s detective shows like “Mannix” that was supposed to sound modern.

Unfortunately for Mangione, the songs he performed from his most recent album “Love Notes” usually fell in the latter category Sunday night. The show had its moments, but they came with older songs that were familiar to the audience. Only one of the newer songs worked nearly as well.

It was Mangione’s 11th SPAC appearance since 1972, only this time his audience size diminished to 4,100. That’s just more than a third of his largest audience in 1978 and down approximately 2,000 from last year. A good third of the crowd opted for lawn seats despite the threat of rain, many because the price of theater seating at 8:15 p.m. events increased dramatically this year.

They saw 1¾ hours of music, opening with “Chase the Clouds Away.” Mangione’s quintet, featuring reedman Chris Vadala and three new players in the rhythm section, ran through three older numbers at first.

Of these, the ABC-commissioned television theme for the 1980 Winter Olympics, “Give It All You’ve Got,” drew a particularly enthusiastic response, and its performance stood out because of the group’s smooth delicacy in handling it, before moving into four songs from “Love Notes.”

The first, “No Problem,” had its share. It built out of a monotonously slow funk with few variations. Nothing except for Vadala and Mangione’s leads sounded the least bit original. This was also a problem on “The Day After Our First Night Together,” which sounded much like the piano section of “Layla.”

“Steppin’ Out (With the One You Love)” worked the best of the new songs and coincidentally sounded the most like pop jazz fusion.

The second set started off strong with three selections from Mangione’s soundtrack for the film “Children of Sanchez.” The Spanish elements Mangione wrote into these songs set off the band, producing its best blend for the night.

On “Eleventh Commandment,” a slow pop melody gave way to some disco-like fusion, with Mangione quoting “Take Me Out to the Ballgame.” He would reprise that melody during his encore.

Mangione seems to work harder as a composer or arranger than as a player. His playing on some numbers sounded particularly effective, mostly because his best melodies call for an essentially understated style on horn.

Sunday’s show began a two-month tour for the group, to promote “Love Notes.” It’s an unenviable task. For the later shows to succeed, Mangione’s going to have to write some stronger material — or just rely on his oldies.