Taylor provides brilliant pop performance
by Matthew Maguire, The Knickerbocker News, July 27, 1982
James Taylor has transcended the mere pop singer-songwriter; his contributions to pop music are so varied and so significant it is no longer blasphemous to mention him in the same breath with Nat King Cole and the handful of other pop music immortals of this century.
The need for such daring superlatives to describe Taylor’s status in the pop world was plain throughout his show Monday night at Saratoga Performing Arts Center — a brilliant display of pop singing and playing, and a reaffirmation of the potential of pop music.
Taylor played the guitar and sang well, as always. Monday, he delivered top-notch renditions of many of his old standards — “Sweet Baby James,” “Up on the Roof,” “Carolina in My Mind,” “You’ve Got a Friend,” “Country Road,” “Fire and Rain,” “How Sweet It Is,” “(For the Love of) Money,” “Shower the People With Love,” and his modern blues classic, “Steamroller Blues.”
Unlike so many pop stars, however, Taylor does not resort to desultory lyric recitations; he makes the subtlest of changes to keep things interesting: “Shower the People” with just his own guitar accompaniment; new phrasings in “Fire and Rain” and “You’ve Got a Friend”; and almost imperceptible tempo changes which give familiar tunes entirely new feelings.
Some of the less familiar material was equally well done. “Bartenders’ Blues,” a narrative country-flavored waltz, is so good it should shame Kenny Rogers into retirement. A Woody Guthrie tune about the benevolent gangster, Pretty Boy Floyd, and a stomping tune about independent truckers also stood out.
Taylor received brilliant support from Billy Payne on keyboards; Dan Dugmore on pedal steel guitar and lead guitar, Andrew Gold on guitar and percussion; Leland Sklar on bass; and Rick Shlosser on drums. This ensemble plays with a quality rare among pop performers — dynamics. This is one of Taylor’s most critical contributions to the genre. In what other comparable band can the drummer play credibly with brushes?
And the brilliant background vocal contributions of Rosemary Butler and Arnold McCuller reflect another of Taylor’s most significant contributions to pop — he has elevated it to an art so delicate his concerts are worth the admittance price if only for that. (For that matter, the breathtaking, three-part wall of sound in the first 16 bars of “Carolina in my Mind” is by itself worth the ticket price.)
Karla Bonoff opened the evening nicely for Taylor with some raw, gritty rock tunes which were marred by muddy sound. Her current hit, the wimpy “Personally,” thankfully is not representative. She is a creditable rock singer with a fine Ronstadt-style delivery.

Recent Comments