Doobies farewell: Self respect intact

by Steve Webb, The Knickerbocker News, August 9, 1982

As the Doobie Brothers took the stage for their farewell concert to the Capital District, the question was obvious: Which Doobie Brothers would this be?

Would it be the coldly calculated band that performed at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center last year, or the pop-soul-rock hit machine that had exhibited a rare sense of swing in its previous SPAC shows?

Sunday’s show at SPAC featured something more like the latter, but more than that really. The Doobie Brothers, a four-piece San Jose group when its 1971 debut album garnered a cult following, had expanded to eight members after numerous membership changes culminating in its decision earlier this year to call it quits.

The hits quit coming, and the departure of bassist Tiran Porter further loosened the band’s ties to its past hits — so the breakup decision was a wise one. But although one could suggest this tour is one last shot at raking in the dough, it was also wise.

The Doobies can leave with their self-respect. Unlike last year’s carefully choreographed show, Sunday’s concert showed the band paying attention to its music — giving something more to the audience than the hits they craved or the slickness they expected.

The band played two sets, 2 1/4 hours of music for 16,600 people. The rain cut the crowd size, which reached 23,000 two of the five other times it played SPAC.

A funk riff set up by bassist Willie Weeks and a trio of percussionists led into an unusual arrangement of “Listen to the Music,” the band’s breakthrough 1973 hit. Group founder Tom Johnston, who sang the original version, is long gone from the band. Keyboardist-saxophonist Cornelius Bumpus sang lead here, a perfect way to lead into that one last retrospective.

Few of the other hits had especially new arrangements. The first set was highlighted by keyboardist Michael McDonald’s breathless rendition of “You Belong to Me,” a song he co-wrote with Carly Simon; McDonald’s title song for the 1980 album “One Step Closer,” and a rousing delivery of the band’s cover of the Isley Brothers “(Take Me in Your Arms and) Rock Me.”

Its disappointment was a muddy version of “Black Water,” the gospel-tinged 1974 hit that sorely missed Porter’s booming baritone. In addition, the sound mix overwhelmed much of the vocals with instrumentation.

The second set featured McDonald’s biggest hits — “Minute by Minute,” “Takin’ It to the Streets” and “What a Fool Believes”.

None of these guys are going to retire after this tour. The supporting musicians work frequently as studio musicians already. But neither McDonald’s “Keep Forgetting” nor Simmons “Out in the Street,” also planned for a solo album, seem destined for post-Doobie hitdom. Time will tell. But area fans can remember the Doobies last tour as one of the summer’s first shows worth getting excited over.