Doobie Bros. give predictable concert

by Bruce Whitney, North Adams Transcript, August 9, 1982

With two years of so-called “farewell tours” under their belts, it seems to me that the Doobie Brothers would have pulled out some surprises to the 16,630 fans last night at Saratoga Performing Arts Center. The California-based band, lauded throughout the world, whipped up an expectedly hit-laden 25-song night, including one quick encore in a satisfying show for the radio listener.

The present Doobie line-up consisted of Patrick Simmons and John McFee on guitars, bassist Willie Weeks, a percussion section of Keith Knudsen, Chet McCracken and Bobby LaKind, and Cornelius Bumpus and Michael McDonald sharing keyboard duties. An eight-man band would require a long evening for each member to get in solo time, so such luxuries were relatively sparse on the whole.

Aside from the dragging that I felt occurred in several pieces, the show certainly put some thoughts and hopes in my mind for a live album. Their overall choice of selections didn’t totally let me down since they included non-singles as “Little Darlin’ (I Need You),” “Nothin’ But A Heartache,” and probably my all-time fave: “Echoes of Love,” which was recorded later by the Pointer Sisters. Their long list of Doobie hits didn’t stop until drummer Knudsen (the K is pronounced, for all you name droppers) finished the show the same as it began, with “Listen To The Music,” their 1972-penned first hit single.

Vocally, everything was crisp, and the harmonies upheld the Doobie’s trademark of multi-levelled smoothness. Simmons and McDonald shared primary lead singing, and it was very obvious that there was a clear separation in each’s compositions and vocals that could define the group’s then-inevitable split-up. Simmons’ vocals are quite clear for a street-oriented rocker, while McDonald has a strong rhythm and blues influence in his oftentimes mystifying and soulful vocals that don’t directly follow the melody of the song. A sneak preview of his soon-to-be-released single and album called “Keep Forgetting” kept the hope alive that McDonald was to keep writing and recording and not become lost in the production studio.

What this show really needed was some unexpected price. You know, the kind that makes anyone unforgivably sorry that they missed the night after following the band’s musical and personnel changes for their 11-year, 10-album lifespan ever since they were known as Pud. In the case of the Doobies, the contributions of past members cannot go unrevived in such a farewell show.

My suggestion to you, oh Brothers Doobie, is that should you plan to spread the ultimate and decisive “Final Farewell Show,” I have a few requests or suggestions… 1) Bring back Tommy Johnston to sing his own songs as a founding father of the Doobies. I’m sure he remembers “Listen to the Music,” “China Grove,” and “Rockin’ Down The Highway” perfectly well. After he heard Cornelius Bumpus’ soulful version of “Long Train Runnin’,” he may let him sing it. 2) Drummer John Hartman’s return would be touching, but I think that Jeff “Skunk” Baxter’s guitar, along with my vote for top Doobie’s bassist Tiran Porter, would really recall the major turning point in these lads’ careers: the Stampede Takin It To The Streets records sound. Porter’s composition of “For Someone Special” would also make for an unforgettable last show. 3) While I’m requesting, this might as well finish my Doobies Christmas list: if there is a next time, surprise us all and have McDonald call up his former Steely Dan-men Walter Becker and Donald Fagen and ask them to join in for their first-ever live appearence.

If that show was ever even rumored, I would not only plan to attend, but I would also consider buying all the Doobie Brothers’ property in the Florida swamps or on the California fault line.