(editor’s note – no ex post facto proof for Duke Jupiter)

(editor’s note – this date was originally scheduled for Joni Mitchell, but she canceled her tour)

Seeing Toto (but thinking Joni Mitchell)

by Steve Webb, The Knickerbocker News, August 17, 1982

No one can blame the Saratoga Performing Arts Center for scheduling Toto, the Los Angeles rock band which performed a perfunctory set to a small crowd there.

The Monday concert was originally slated to feature Joni Mitchell, who canceled her summer tour probably because her latest album won’t be out until autumn. Advance ticket sales for Ms. Mitchell exceeded the 2,500 sold for Toto.

But on the face of it, the late booking of this hard rock band made commercial sense. After all, how much is a hit single worth as a concert draw? “Rosanna” stayed in the No. 2 position for a solid month, and the band’s album “Toto IV” still lingers in the Top Five.

But the low attendance indicates that even the local rock fans buying the album know a stiff live band when they hear it. Toto offered a loud, dense 11/2 hours of music that had precious little swing, even less variety and even less originality. It is a group of talented players that has very little to offer creatively.

One couldn’t sit in the SPAC amphitheater without thinking about Ms. Mitchell, a less skillful musician than Toto’s David Paich but an infinitely superior songwriter and a more effective musician because she approaches music as art.

Actually, a far better songwriter than Paich sang background Monday night, former Poco and Eagles bassist Timothy Schmit. The show began with some interesting rear-projection animation of Toto corporate logos to their instrumental “Child’s Anthem.” None of the songs matched the melodic flair of that anthem, and several of them included passages curiously resembling such rock standards as the Who’s “Amazing Journey,” the Rolling Stones’ “Let’s Spend the Night Together” and other riffs I couldn’t immediately name.

“Rosanna” worked, as did the latest single “Make Believe,” because their pop hooks were presented amid more interesting rhythms. The playing was right, but hey — the listener might as well have stayed at home with the record. Apparently most did.


The Knickerbocker News, August 16, 1982