Box-office champ Genesis sounds like a band this time

by Steve Webb, The Knickerbocker News, August 28, 1982

Genesis’ 2 1/4-hour show at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center was the first in three center performances that this British aggregation actually seemed like a band.

The veteran “art rock” group performed a variety of its material Thursday, using more of its older and less commercial songs than before to 26,500 people — probably the largest crowd SPAC will see all year.

The band performed at SPAC in 1978 and 1980 for “only” about 10,000 people each. Those shows were hurt by the concert format of the band’s personnel. A trio that heavily overdubs its records in the studio, Genesis uses auxiliary guitarist Daryl Stuermer and drummer Chester Thompson on tour. Before, it seemed very much like two guys playing with three guys.

But Thursday’s performance was like a band, a development hinted at by Genesis’ latest in-concert album, “Three Sides Live.” Stuermer seems to have more confidence playing guitar alongside guitarist-bassist Mike Rutherford, and Thompson has developed his own groove in a group that features one of Britain’s best rock drummers as lead vocalist.

For his part, Phil Collins played more drums than in the previous two concerts. When he and Thompson dueted, as they did on several extended instrumentals, they complemented each other.

All of these improvements meant the band has developed the kind of rhythmic undercurrent so essential to being a rock band. They make the melodic patterns keyboardist Tony Banks maps out seem less elementary, and Collins’ theatrics as a vocalist seem less pretentious. The music still doesn’t overshadow Genesis ‘ brilliantly designed light show, but it comes closer.

The lights deserve more description than most concerts’ lights do. The stage was like a large painting, with even the band members and equipment diffused among clouds of smoke shaded by pastel pinks, oranges, and yellow one moment, hard reds and greens another moment and bars of white light the next.

The eyes struggle to focus on a bank of turquoise-lit amplifiers and drums behind magenta-lit musicians at the front of the stage. Many fast chord changes in the music were punctuated by rapid shifts of lighting the stage solely in yellow, orange, red, green, two shades of blue and a deep violet.

Only two things marred the evening. One was Collins’ tastelessly sexist introduction to “Supper is Ready,” a rape-fantasy anecdote that somehow drew cheers in the audience. The other was a muddy quality that pervaded the sound mix, rendering much of Collins’ singing unintelligible. For a band whose lyrics seem so obscure to begin with, this development was often maddening.

But on the whole, the show was worthy of its attendance. This writer will never become a fan of this band, but Thursday’s show seemed to play on its members’ assets to better effect than previous ones.