SPAC closer: ‘Fine music, too many gimmicks’

by Leonard Stuart, The Knickerbocker News, September 7, 1976

In keeping with its name, the Electric Light Orchestra travels with a spectacular light show, bouncing the green beam of a laser from huge mirror balls hung high above the front and back of the stage to produce effects that turn an auditorium into something reminiscent of a 1968 psychedelic ballroom.

Unfortunately, when they overuse the gimmick, as they did in their performance before a near-capacity crowd at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center (SPAC) here Saturday night, it gets distracting and takes away from their otherwise fine music.

That’s a shame because the seven-member British unit, led by guitarist Jeff Lynne, does some very interesting things combining classical instrumentation and style with rock and roll. Their music features a four-man rock lineup—Lynne on guitar, plus bass, drums and keyboards—supplemented by a string section of two cellos and a violin.

The instrumental texture of the sound is rather unusual, with the strings used to spice up the sound the way many other bands are lately employing horns.

Visually, it’s even more unusual to see the cello, an instrument generally thought of only in rather stodgy chamber concerts, played with the kind of energy and abandon associated with rock.

That included musical “High Noon” faceoffs between violinist Mik Kaminski and Lynne a la the heavy metal school, and cellist Hugh McDowall’s playing of his instrument upside down behind his head.

The group ran through the obligatory catalog of hits, beginning with “Night Rider” from its most recent album “Face the Music” and ending with “Do Ya,” a cut from an album due for release in November, already out as a single.

They saved the even more inevitable “Roll Over Beethoven” for an encore.

Their best pieces of the night were ballads, on the order of the hits “Strange Magic” and “Can’t Get It Out of My Head,” which showed off the vocalists’ abilities at pleasant harmonies.

The band tried hard to generate some excitement for the crowd in the chill Saratoga air, but it finally took the hit “Evil Woman” to get the audience up and dancing in the face of the usual stringent SPAC security.

Sound mixing was spotty throughout the concert, fine in a few spots but so muddy in others there was little definition of instrumental sound and the cellos or violin were temporarily lost.

Lynne composes most of the group’s music, and he has been called one of the “most creative musical thiefs at large,” drawing influences from everywhere from the Beatles and Bob Dylan to Aaron Copland.

The other members of the group are Richard Tandy on keyboards and guitar; Kelly Groucutt on bass and vocals; Mik Kaminskiy on violin, and Hugh McDowall and Melvyn Gale on cellos.

Saturday night’s opening act, a group called Widowmaker, was so bad it almost defies description. The rhythm guitarist spent the entire set running laps from one end of the stage to the other (honestly) and not paying much attention to his instrument.

One of the stranger points of the evening was the arrival of a tour bus with a group of 50 or so people, the youngest of whom looked around 40.

After standing for a while at the back of the amphitheater in their polyesters and orthopedic shoes, gazing in amazement at the antics of the opening act, they were led down the center aisle to a large block of seats in the choicest center section of the auditorium—the gamer ones, that is, who didn’t return to the bus at that time.

A few of them actually sat through ELO’s entire performance, but most of them got up and walked out after the band’s first two or three songs.

None of the security people questioned had any explanation for the group’s presence, and when questioned, the theater manager said as far as he knew, the group had purchased tickets for the performance.

But then, maybe they thought they were getting an orchestra.