Heartfelt, but uneven

New topical songs snag Baez concert

by Steve Webb, The Knickerbocker News, June 28, 1982

In her song “Children of the ’80s,” folk singer Joan Baez writes about young people who live today, but long for the time two decades ago when the Beatles and the Doors were together. When Bob Dylan hadn’t discovered Jesus, Jimi and Janis were alive. When a previous generation of young people was marching and tripping and going to rock festivals.

Others have made the same observation, but Ms. Baez’s thoughts come from a variety of letters she solicited and received from her own younger fans. She performed the song in her concert for 2,900 people Sunday at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center, one of several of her new songs that worked better when she explained them than when she sang them.

In some ways, it was a pleasant and stimulating show. At 41, Ms. Baez’s vocal gift is still impressive. She also has a knack for tying the pop tradition to the folk tradition when she sings the theme from “The Rose” early in her first set, refers to the movie in “Children of the ’80s,” and then comes closest to matching the earlier song’s atmosphere and theme with the traditional song “Barbara Allen.”

The singer also has a way of presenting her politics and her self in the context of her art in a wholly comfortable way. Her anecdotes were wonderful, particularly one self-deprecating story about being determined not to perform to a segregated audience in Alabama during the height of the civil rights movement, “only nobody black had heard of me, and they didn’t go.”

The show’s failings centered on her new songs, which she recorded for an album that she is no longer trying to release. One was a paean to Lech Walesa. Another was a tribute to the non-violent fighters of the present decade.

Her lyrics are much like the poetry of Ralph Waldo Emerson. Her voice, her thoughts, her point of view and — yes — her life are more poetic than her actual verse. Strangely, her most effective original songs performed Sunday derived from experiences more personal than political, “Honest Lullaby” and “Diamonds and Rust.”

Regardless, much of the concert was jarring, starting with her performance of Bob Dylan’s “With God on Our Side” in the first set. In the second set, the last group of songs, including “I Dreamed I Saw Joe Hill,” Dylan’s “A Hard Rain’s Gonna Fall” and John Lennon’s “Imagine” worked so well they were haunting.

Her admiration for Dylan, which many believe is reflected in the 1975 hit “Diamonds and Rust,” makes her the perfect curator for many of the songs he has abandoned. “Hard Rain” is alive when she sings it, not just a curio from the Cuban missile crisis. As she noted, “God on Our Side” is more relevant today than in 1963 when it was written.

Interpreting Dylan, however, isn’t all Ms. Baez has going for her as an artist. This most recent concert was only a mixed success, but it indicates she still articulates a strong human-rights position in the context of song.