Cooper upstages Sergio, off-form Dana at SPAC
by Bruce Husten, The Knickerbocker News, August 4, 1976
In the history of special events at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center, a precedent has been set for the “warm-up group” to steal the limelight from the featured attraction.
It happened several years ago when Mac Davis, who did the warm-up for The Carpenters, stole the show, and it happened again last summer when Neil Sedaka, also warming up The Carpenters, grabbed most of the audience’s affection and attention.
And it happened once again at SPAC last night, when comedian Pat Cooper pulled off a real coup by upstaging both Sergio Franchi (Cooper’s friend and neighbor in Las Vegas) and Franchi’s sister, Dana Valery.
And this is quite an admission from one who is not terribly fond of stand-up comedians.
But Cooper walked on stage with such zest and enthusiasm and determination to captivate his audience that the crowd of 4,300 was with him all the way. He is dynamic in his delivery and confident about his content, which combines ethnic jokes with one-liners that hit you with the everyday realities with which we live.
Dana Valery opened the show and endeared the audience more with her stunning physical presence than her vocal felicity. Her act suffered a bit from acoustical problems in the amphitheater (which clearly were not her fault) as well as from pitch and enunciation problems (which clearly were). By the time she finished with “Could It Be Magic,” however, she had it all together, and this sensitive rendition brought the audience to its feet.
Franchi himself seemed to walk—or perhaps gracefully waltz—through the second half of the show. He was not in good vocal form and at first seemed apathetic about performing at all. (When he brought his sister out again during his act, in fact, we overheard one member of the audience comment: “I bet he’s doing this tour just to promote her.”)
Most of his material seemed obligatory in the summer of ’76 (how many more times will we hear “Feelings” and “I Write the Songs” performed this summer?) or else inevitable from Franchi (“Volare,” “Al Di La” and a couple of medleys of other Italian love ballads), and the voice itself seemed shrill, wavering from flat to sharp and with a vibrato reminiscent of Maria Callas on her way down.
Surprisingly, however, Franchi has a wonderful stage presence, and the most enjoyable part of his portion of the evening came in his spontaneous, casual repartee with the audience. He is more relaxed on stage than most entertainers we’ve seen, and while one might accuse him of both apathy and vocal deficiency in his performance last night, he certainly compensated with some refreshing dialogue. He is really charming.
His “Mama” and his “Pagliacci” aria were sentimentally lovely, and his counterpoint duet with his sister (Dana doing “As Time Goes By” and Sergio simultaneously doing “For Once in My Life”) was certainly a highlight. But his “Fiddler on the Roof” medley, with the motif altered in lyrics from Jewish to Italian, seemed unworkable from the staff.
The evening was a long one, and both Cooper and Franchi could have cut their acts a bit, but the audience wallowed in it.

Recent Comments